The prison without walls
Covert narcissism as an existential deadlock
​
​
Introduction – the paradox of covert narcissism
Covert narcissism is not a storm you can hear approaching from afar, but a quiet disturbance in the weather. It doesn’t arrive with loud claims of grandeur or overt dominance, but with a blend of vulnerability, subtlety and apparent innocence. Where overt narcissism flaunts itself in visible, noisy displays of splendor and control, covert narcissism remains in the shadows — and it is precisely there that it unfolds its greatest power.
Its tragedy is twofold. On the one hand, it is a personality structure that is, at its core, almost hermetically sealed off from self-reflection and change. On the other, it is this very closedness that warps relationships, wounds people and rewrites realities to serve a single goal: the preservation of one’s own illusion.
This illusion is no frivolous lie. It is a survival mechanism, meticulously constructed to shield a deep inner vulnerability. The problem is that this protection becomes impenetrable — both to the person themselves and to anyone who tries to get closer.
In therapy, this often means that the door to change only opens a crack when external pressure is inescapable. Left to themselves, that door rarely opens, because taking responsibility feels like risking a total inner collapse. Not only because the protective structure would crumble, but because acknowledging the truth is unbearable: admitting the chaos, pain and damage one has caused. Not only within oneself, but also seeing what has been broken in others — and realizing that one’s own actions were the cause. To truly face themselves, they would have to look through the façade that has shielded them all their lives. The fear of doing so is so great that the illusion always wins.
Thus arises a human and societal deadlock. The narcissist lives trapped in a construct that protects them, yet wounds others. It is a prison without walls — invisible, yet inescapable. And while the outside world bears the consequences, the inner world remains unchanged, guarded by the illusion that is cherished as the highest good.
This deadlock unfolds not only on a relational and societal level, but also deep within the psychological structure of the covert narcissist. To understand why change is so difficult, we must examine the mechanisms that keep this structure intact.
​
The Psychological Core – The Impossibility of Responsibility
In clinical literature, covert narcissism is often described through traits such as hypersensitivity to criticism, a chronic sense of being wronged and subtle forms of manipulation. Where overt narcissists dominate their environment with visible arrogance and superiority, the covert narcissist presents more as a victim, a misunderstood genius or a quiet martyr. But behind this façade lies the same core problem: a fragile, unstable self-image that must be protected at all costs.
Psychologically, this protective mechanism functions as a closed system. It runs on three mutually reinforcing processes:
Projection and Externalization
All inner tension, shame, and guilt are placed outside the self.
Problems, conflicts, and failures are attributed to others or to circumstances. This prevents their own vulnerability from being exposed, but makes genuine self-examination nearly impossible.
Gaslighting and Reality Distortion
To keep the illusion intact, reality is actively rewritten. This can be subtle — omitting facts, reframing events — or more extreme, by making another person systematically doubt their own perception. For the covert narcissist, this distortion is not a lie in the classic sense, but a necessary truth that preserves internal coherence.
Chronic Avoidance of Responsibility
Taking responsibility would mean the façade crumbling. But the real threat lies in what comes next: the confrontation with one’s own actions. Acknowledging the chaos, pain, and harm one has caused requires facing the destructive potential within. It means looking at oneself without a mask — and that image can be unbearable. The fear of such self-confrontation is so great that the illusion is defended at all costs — even if it means distorting or denying the reality of others.
The situation becomes even more complex when people with covert narcissism display a form of self-reflection. At times, they can articulate with striking precision what is wrong — someone might openly admit to being selfish or to sabotaging relationships through distrust or emotional withdrawal. Yet this insight almost never leads to actual change. There is no genuine behavioral transformation, because the self-reflection is not aimed at transformation, but at controlling the narrative. By choosing the right words, they can create the impression of openness and honesty, while the core remains untouched. Even the moment in front of the mirror is used as part of the façade: a strategic move to gain trust or neutralize criticism, without endangering the illusion.
The result is a psychological deadlock: the self is shielded by walls of denial, but those same walls also keep out growth, connection and healing. In therapy, this often leads to resistance, subtle undermining, or premature dropout — unless there is unavoidable external pressure, such as a relationship ending, the threat of unemployment or legal consequences.
But even then, a covert narcissist rarely gives themselves away. Their charm, verbal skill and ability to reshape stories often make them appear credible — even to experienced professionals. It takes a therapist with specific expertise in this treacherous personality structure, someone who can see through the layers of victimhood, half-truths, and emotional manipulation.
​
Without such sharpness and experience, the heart of the problem is likely to remain hidden — exactly as the person with covert narcissism intends. From a clinical perspective, this resistance is understandable: the personality structure was born as a survival strategy, often rooted in early childhood experiences of abandonment, rejection, and/or emotional neglect. The tragedy is that the very structure that once offered protection now makes change nearly impossible.
Where these psychological mechanisms form the building blocks of the illusion, the existential dimension reveals what it means to live within that illusion. Here, the focus shifts from the how to the what and why — to the experience of an existence in which truth and self-image are under constant management.
The Existential Dimension – Trapped in One’s Own Illusion
Living with covert narcissism is living in a carefully staged reality. Everything in the inner world serves the maintenance of a single illusion: that one is innocent, misunderstood or simply not good at relationships. This illusion is not a superficial lie, but a complete life construction. It is the lens through which the world is seen, the script from which one lives and the stage upon which one performs oneself.
In existential terms, Sartre might call this a form of bad faith: denying one’s own freedom and responsibility by hiding behind roles, stories and circumstances.
​
Kierkegaard would call it a form of despair — the “sickness unto death” — in which one refuses to become the true self, out of fear of what that self might reveal.
Erich Fromm described it as an escape from freedom: avoiding the fear and responsibility that come with authentic living, by clinging to a constructed identity.
​
The narcissistic self, in this sense, is a role that cannot be set aside. Without it lies emptiness — a loss of identity that feels like existential annihilation. This is why everything — relationships, conversations, memories, even facts and people — can be rewritten if necessary to keep the script intact.
The illusion becomes the highest good, because it manipulates not only the outside world, but above all, it protects the inner one. No price is too high to preserve it: the reality of others may be sacrificed, connections may be disrupted or severed and the pursuit of truth can be exchanged for convincing fiction. The tragedy is that the narcissist is their own greatest prisoner. But it is a captivity in which the key will always remain out of reach — because they themselves do not want to know that such a key even exists.
And so the deadlock remains: as long as the illusion is intact, the inner foundation stands. But it is precisely this foundation that makes true connection, growth and healing impossible.
Yet the most painful paradox is this: however safe the bubble of illusion may seem, it offers no real happiness. Covert narcissists rarely, if ever, experience the joy of authentic connection or inner peace. Even behind the façade, there lingers a persistent emptiness and an inability to feel deep joy or contentment. Many, including my ex, have even said it outright: that they have never truly been happy in their lives. The illusion protects them from pain, but at the same time closes the door to the only thing that could truly soothe that pain.
​
This inner prison seldom leaves the outside world untouched. What happens inside inevitably seeps into relationships, families and other systems, where the illusion is always searching for new ground in which to take root.
The Societal Dimension – The Destructive Deadlock
Where covert narcissism exists, it is never merely a private matter. The illusion that protects the inner structure works like a slowly expanding shadow over its surroundings. Partners, children, family, colleagues and friends become part of the stage play — often without realizing it.
In intimate relationships, this manifests as subtle undermining: small shifts in reality, inducing guilt, triangulation or the erosion of the other’s self-confidence. In families, children may grow up in an inverted reality, subjected to systematic gaslighting in which their perceptions are denied and their emotions minimized. In the workplace, the covert narcissist can present as indispensable, while beneath the surface unrest, division and mistrust quietly spreads.
From a societal perspective, the greatest challenge is that covert narcissism is rarely visible to outsiders. The façade is often charming, empathetic and socially well-adapted. In legal or professional settings, they are frequently believed over their victims, simply because their verbal skill and charm allow them to deliver a smooth, convincing story. This deepens the isolation of those affected and prolongs the life of the illusion.
Even in the realm of intimacy, reality can be distorted. Sexuality may not only be a space for closeness, but also a subtle instrument of power. It can be used to bind, confuse or control — sometimes by deliberately withholding it, sometimes by using it as a reward or as a weapon. For partners, this can be profoundly destabilizing, as it strikes at a deeply human need for recognition and connection. What should be a space for vulnerability instead becomes a stage for control and reinforcement of the illusion.
Therapeutically, all this presents a complex challenge. Even if a covert narcissist enters therapy under external pressure, there is a high risk that the process will be manipulated. They say what is desirable to hear, reinterpret events to their advantage or subtly turn the therapist against others. Without a practitioner who has both experience and specialized knowledge of this personality structure, the core of the problem will remain untouched. And as long as that core is left intact, the pattern will inevitably repeat.
This creates a societal deadlock: the person cannot or will not change, yet continues to actively influence relationships and systems in ways that are destructive. For those around them, it is difficult — if not impossible — to set lasting boundaries, because the manipulation often appears invisible and socially acceptable. The result is that entire systems — families, relationships, even teams — slowly adapt to the illusion, until the lie is experienced as the norm.
And while the covert narcissist usually escapes scrutiny, it is those around them who ultimately pay the price. Partners, children, familly and friends are the ones who end up in therapy, seeking to repair their self-image, their trust and their sense of reality. They bear the emotional scars of a battle that is seldom acknowledged, trying to relearn in therapy what truth, safety and connection truly mean.
When we bring together all these layers — the psychological, the existential and the societal — the full picture of the deadlock that is covert narcissism emerges. It is in this totality that the real tragedy comes into view.
​
Conclusion – The Tragedy Behind the Façade
Covert narcissism is more than a collection of traits listed in a manual. It is a world unto itself — a carefully constructed reality in which the illusion is the foundation and truth is a threat.
Psychologically, it is a closed system: every attempt at self-examination collides with walls of denial, the rewriting of stories, and strategic avoidance.
Existentially, it is a refusal to face the true self — a flight into roles and scripts that shield against the unbearable weight of responsibility.
The societal consequences reach far beyond what is visible. Partners, children, parents, siblings, colleagues and friends bear the scars of a battle that often remains outside the gaze of the public. Their truth has been distorted, their self-confidence eroded and their reality slowly but surely rewritten. Many eventually find their way to therapy — not to recover from their own actions, but from the consequences of someone else’s maintenance of an illusion. Meanwhile, the narcissist themselves often stays outside the therapy room, safe within the walls of their own narrative.
The tragedy is twofold. On one side, there is the person trapped in a personality structure that once served as protection but now blocks every path to healing. On the other, there are those who have been wounded by that very structure — broken in the places that once formed the core of their trust. Thus the greatest deadlock of all arises: no change is possible without the death of the illusion, but for the narcissist, the death of that illusion feels like the death of themselves.
Perhaps this is the essence of this prison without walls: the key lies in truth and responsibility, yet it is precisely this key that is most feared. And as long as the fear of self-confrontation remains greater than the will for freedom, the walls will stay invisible — both to themselves and to the many who live, or have lived, too close to their shadow.
